Best Car Insurance Companies in California for Drivers with Multiple Claims

Finding the right car insurance company can be particularly challenging for drivers in California with multiple claims on their record. Insurance providers often assess risk based on past driving history, which can make securing affordable coverage more complicated for those with a higher number of claims. To help you navigate this landscape, we've compiled a list of the best car insurance companies in California for drivers facing this situation.

1. State Farm
State Farm is renowned for its extensive network of agents and exceptional customer service. For drivers with multiple claims, they provide options for coverage that can help mitigate costs. Their Drive Safe & Save program offers discounts based on driving behavior, which can be an advantage for cautious drivers looking to improve their record and save on premiums.

2. Progressive
Progressive is known for its flexible policy options and competitive pricing. They offer programs like the Snapshot tool that tracks driving habits and can lead to significant savings for safe drivers. For those with multiple claims, Progressive’s “Name Your Price” tool allows customers to adjust coverage limits according to their budget, which can be particularly useful for managing costs.

3. Geico
Geico is another popular choice for drivers with multiple claims in California. Their easy-to-use online system and 24/7 customer service make it convenient for policyholders to manage their accounts. Geico offers a variety of discounts that can benefit drivers with a less-than-perfect record, including multi-policy discounts if you bundle your car insurance with other coverage such as homeowners insurance.

4. Allstate
Allstate provides a unique range of options for drivers with multiple claims. Their Claim Satisfaction Guarantee ensures that if policyholders are not satisfied with how their claim was handled, they could receive a policy refund. Additionally, Allstate offers a wide array of discounts for good driving habits, which can be appealing for those looking to improve their record.

5. Farmers Insurance
Farmers Insurance is well-known for accommodating drivers with multiple claims. They offer personalized service and support, helping you find the best coverage tailored to your needs. Their extensive range of policies includes options that can protect against high-risk factors, which can be crucial for drivers with a spotty claim history.

6. Mercury Insurance
Mercury Insurance is particularly popular among California drivers for its affordability. They cater to those who may have many claims, offering flexible payment plans and various discounts. Their local agents are knowledgeable about California regulations and can provide personalized advice to help lessen the impact of multiple claims on your insurance rates.

7. USAA
If you are a military member or a veteran, USAA offers some of the best rates and coverage options available. Their customer service is highly rated, and they are known for working with customers to find the best coverage, even if past claims have complicated the situation. USAA’s commitment to serving military families makes it an appealing choice for those eligible.

When searching for car insurance in California with multiple claims, it’s crucial to compare quotes from various providers to find the best coverage at the most competitive rates. Many insurers provide tools and resources to help drivers assess their needs and make informed choices. Consider looking for discounts, utilizing safe driving programs, and speaking directly with agents to find the most suitable policy for your circumstances.

If you have a history of multiple claims, don’t be discouraged. With the right insurance provider and proactive steps towards improving your driving habits, you can secure affordable car insurance in California.

Go To Top