Best Car Insurance Deals in California for Drivers with a History of Accidents

Finding the right car insurance in California can be a daunting task, especially for those with a history of accidents. However, there are numerous options available that cater specifically to high-risk drivers, allowing them to find affordable coverage without sacrificing quality. Below, we explore some of the best car insurance deals for California drivers who have had accidents in the past.

1. Geico
Geico is known for its competitive rates and has specific programs designed for drivers with a checkered past. With a user-friendly online platform and a range of discounts available, including safe driving and multi-policy discounts, Geico can help make premiums more affordable for high-risk drivers in California.

2. Progressive
Progressive is another great option for California drivers with a history of accidents. They offer a unique feature called the "Name Your Price" tool, allowing drivers to specify how much they want to pay. This flexibility can be particularly helpful for those with a poor driving record. Additionally, Progressive’s Snapshot program rewards safe driving, potentially lowering rates over time.

3. State Farm
State Farm is one of the largest car insurance providers in the country and offers personalized service through local agents. Their Drive Safe & Save program can lead to discounts for drivers who exhibit safe driving habits. For those with accident histories, State Farm also provides coverage options that might suit their situation without exorbitant costs.

4. Allstate
Allstate provides insurance packages tailored for high-risk drivers. Their Drivewise program offers significant savings for safe driving practices tracked via a mobile app. For drivers who may have accidents on their records, Allstate also has the option of accident forgiveness after a set number of safe years, which can lead to better rates in the long run.

5. Farmers Insurance
Farmers Insurance offers unique solutions for California drivers by providing customizable coverage options. They excel in providing services to high-risk individuals, with various discounts available for bundled insurance (such as home and auto) and maintaining a low mileage. Farmers also focuses on creating personalized policies to meet the needs of drivers with accident histories.

6. USAA
If you’re a member of the military or have a familial connection to the military, USAA offers some of the best rates for car insurance, even for drivers with accident records. Their policies are focused on members and often come with comprehensive benefits while maintaining competitive pricing.

7. Mercury Insurance
Mercury Insurance is a California-based company well-regarded for offering competitive policies for high-risk drivers. They focus on providing affordable coverage options and often are more lenient with driving records compared to larger insurance providers. This makes them an excellent choice for drivers looking for reasonable rates.

In conclusion, while a history of accidents can make securing affordable car insurance in California challenging, several companies provide solid options. By comparing different providers and considering specific programs and discounts, drivers can find the best deals that cater to their unique situations. It's advisable to get quotes from multiple companies and evaluate what coverage works best for your needs. Don’t forget to ask about possible discounts and consumer reviews to ensure you're making an informed decision during your search.

Go To Top